Why does the way you pay matter so much on a sublet?
Pay for a sublet last, and pay in a way that leaves a record tied to a real person and a signed sublease. The payment method is your last line of defense, not your first. Seeing the place, knowing who holds the lease and getting the landlord's okay in writing protect you more than any app or card does.
The method still matters, because some of them cannot be undone. The FTC says that wiring money, sending gift cards or paying by cryptocurrency is the same as sending cash, and that you probably cannot get it back. Its advice on payment apps says scammers know that once you send money, it is hard for you to get it back.
The amounts are not small. Wroomly's live rent data (the Ann Arbor rent prices guide, read 2026-11-03) puts the median asking rent at $1,900 a month across 151 active sublets. If the deposit is one month's rent, a deposit plus first month is $3,800 in one move.
Wroomly processes no payments, never holds or guarantees money, and cannot recover money sent between users. Whatever channel you found the place on, the payment is between you and the person you pay. That is why the checks come first.
What has to be true before you pay anything?
Get all of these done first. If any one is missing, the answer to a request for money is not yet.
One more rule sits above the list: if anyone pressures you to decide fast, walk away. The FTC gives the same advice for rental listings, and a real sublet survives a day of checking.
- You have seen the place, in person or on a live video walkthrough where the person opens the rooms and doors you ask about
- You know who the person is and that they hold the lease or own the place. A blue check on Wroomly shows someone signed in with a umich Google account, and nothing more
- The landlord or leasing office has approved the sublet in writing, and you reached them through contact details you found yourself
- You have a written sublease with the dates, the rent, the deposit amount, who holds the deposit and when it comes back
- The name on the payment matches the name on the sublease. A request to pay a friend, a relative or a business partner instead is a stop sign
- The payment method is one you can explain in a sentence, and it is not the only one the person will accept
Which payment methods leave a record and which do not?
Two questions sort the methods: can the payment be reversed if it turns out to be fraud, and what proof does it leave of who got your money and why. The table uses the FTC's own pages on what to do if you were scammed. Where those pages say nothing, the table says so rather than guessing.
Where does Zelle fit? The FTC's payment app advice names Cash App, Venmo and PayPal, and it does not name Zelle. Reversal rules for bank to bank apps depend on your bank, so read your bank's own terms before you rely on a refund. Until your bank tells you otherwise in writing, treat Zelle like any other app.
| Method | Can it be reversed? (as the FTC describes it) | The record it leaves | When it is acceptable |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash | The FTC describes one rescue: mailed cash that has not yet been delivered may be intercepted by the Postal Inspection Service. Cash handed over in person has no route back | Only a receipt, and the person writes it | Rarely. Only in person, after every check above, against a signed receipt |
| Wire transfer | The FTC says to report it to the wire transfer company right away and ask for a refund, but the money might be gone already. It also says wiring money is the same as sending cash | A bank record of the transfer, to an account you cannot vet | Not with anyone you have not met and checked |
| Gift card or cryptocurrency | The FTC says crypto payments do not have the same legal protections as credit and debit cards, and a gift card issuer may or may not refund you | Almost nothing you can use | Never for a sublet. The FTC lists insisting on crypto as a sign of a scam |
| Payment app (Venmo, Cash App, PayPal and similar) | The FTC says to report it to the app and ask for a reversal and a refund, and it does not promise one | A transaction history with the payee's name and a note you write | Only after every check above, to the person named on the sublease, with a note that says what it is for |
| Personal check | The FTC pages do not describe how to reverse a check you wrote | A paper trail: payee, date, memo line and your bank statement | After every check above, made out to the name on the sublease, with the purpose in the memo. Never deposit a check someone sends you and send money back |
| Debit or credit card | The FTC says to report it to the card issuer or bank right away and ask for a refund. Its legal protection covers unauthorized use of your card, which is not the same as a payment you were tricked into making | A statement with the merchant or payee | Best record of the lot, when the person can take one |
How should the deposit and first month be documented?
Treat the paperwork as part of the payment. The record is what lets you prove what you paid, to whom and for what, and it is what you will lean on when the deposit comes back. Your lease and your sublease decide the terms, so ask the landlord or a lawyer what a clause means rather than guessing.
The security deposits guide covers move-in photos and getting a deposit returned. Here is the paperwork for the payment itself:
- Pay the deposit and the first month as two payments, each with its own note naming the sublet address and what the money is for
- Get a written receipt with the date, the amount, who paid, who received it, what it covers, who holds the deposit and when and how it comes back
- Make sure the amounts on the receipt match the signed sublease
- Keep screenshots of the listing, the messages and the payment confirmation in one folder
- Never pay a deposit and then ask for the sublease later
What should you do if money already went to a scammer?
Stop paying right away, even if the person has a new reason to ask for more. Then work through the list below, and keep every screenshot and receipt. Recovery is not promised on any method, so move quickly and ask plainly.
The FTC's steps depend on how you paid. For a card, call the issuer or your bank. For a wire, call the wire transfer company. For a gift card, call the issuer and keep the card and receipt. For crypto, contact the exchange or ATM operator. For a payment app, report it inside the app. For mailed cash, call the Postal Inspection Service at once.
- Contact the company you paid with, tell them it was fraud and ask them to reverse the payment
- Report the scam to the FTC at ReportFraud on the FTC site
- Report the listing to the website or group where you found it
- Tell your local police and your state attorney general
- Warn the group or friends who might see the same listing
Where should you go from here?
Read the Wroomly safety page for what the blue check and listing screening do and do not prove, then browse current sublets and run every one through the checklist above before any money moves.
Explore
Frequently asked questions
Is it safe to pay a sublet deposit with Zelle or Venmo?
Only after you have seen the place, confirmed the person holds the lease and signed a sublease, and only to the name on that sublease. The FTC says money sent through a payment app is hard to get back. With a stranger, or before a viewing, the answer is no.
Can you get money back from Venmo if a sublet was fake?
Maybe, but nothing guarantees it. The FTC says to report the payment to the app right away, ask for a reversal and a refund, and report the scam to the FTC. Move fast, keep screenshots of the listing and messages, and do not count on the money returning.
Should you ever pay for a sublet in cash?
Rarely. Cash handed over in person leaves no record unless you insist on a signed receipt, and the FTC describes no route to get it back. If it happens at all, do it in person after you have seen the place, checked the landlord's approval and signed the sublease.
What receipt should you get for a sublet deposit?
A written receipt showing the date, amount, who paid, who received it, what it covers, who holds the deposit and when and how it comes back. The amounts should match the signed sublease. Keep it with your payment confirmation and move-in photos in one folder.
